809 Poinsettia Drive, EUSTIS, FL 32726
Property Photos

Would you like to sell your home before you purchase this one?
Priced at Only: $420,000
For more Information Call:
Address: 809 Poinsettia Drive, EUSTIS, FL 32726
Property Location and Similar Properties
- MLS#: O6291535 ( Single Family )
- Street Address: 809 Poinsettia Drive
- Viewed: 1
- Price: $420,000
- Price sqft: $137
- Waterfront: No
- Year Built: 1926
- Bldg sqft: 3057
- Bedrooms: 3
- Total Baths: 2
- Full Baths: 2
- Days On Market: 4
- Additional Information
- Geolocation: 28.8436 / -81.6771
- County: LAKE
- City: EUSTIS
- Zipcode: 32726
- Subdivision: Eustis Hillcrest Sub
- Elementary School: Eustis Heights Elem
- Middle School: Eustis Middle
- High School: Eustis High School
- Provided by: ATRIUM REALTY, LLC
- Contact: Laura Krupar
- DMCA Notice
-
DescriptionEvery day is retreat at this hilltop abode overlooking Lake Gracie. This charming Spanish style home is surrounded by lush landscaping with ample places to enjoy bird sounds and water views from the large back deck to the paved patio with fire pit to a covered hot tub and nearby highly desired lakeside walking loop. Find peace and tranquility here. This historic home has been tastefully updated and meticulously maintained. Some highlights include beautifully finished original wood flooring throughout the formal living and dining room, original wood trim, warm and calming paint colors, charming French doors, and ample windows that give this home a light and airy feel. Some recent improvements include a new roof (2022), new water heater (2025), new deck (2022) and deck reinforcement, new fencing (2017), and new window awnings (2021). On the main level, you will find a formal living room with artistically tiled decorative fireplace which flows to the main dining room and onto the kitchen and second living area with views of the trees and lake beyond. There is one bedroom at the front of the house with a close by large hallway bath with a bright and spacious shower area. The primary suite, with a spa like en suite and again lake views, is tucked at the back of the main level. While there is no access to the basement level from the interior of the main level of the home, this allows complete privacy for the lower level that houses the third bedroom, potential fourth bedroom or office space, a living space as well as a laundry area and a large storage room. This creates a unique option for an IN LAW SUITE or AIR BNB and could also be used as a home office, an artists studio, music studio, or a gym/yoga room. There is currently no bath on the basement level, however water supply and drains are easily accessible. With a little imagination and creativity, you could design this space to accommodate your specific needs. A private driveway leads close to the lower levels door for easy access. There is additional parking space on the left side of the property as well as a hook up to charge an RV or camper. Beyond what your eyes can see as you walk through this charming space, this home has a rich history in the city of Eustis. Based on public records, this home was built in 1926 by the Vogt Family (who started the citys first newspaper) after they purchased the land from the Ferran family in 1925. Edgar Ferran and his family moved to Eustis in 1884, just nine years after Eustis became a city (1875), and had a thriving business, Ferrans Department Store, which was a staple in the area for decades. Edgar Ferran is commemorated with the lakeside park that bears his name Ferran Park, located near Eustis downtown and Lake Eustis boardwalk. Come see all that this historic home and retreats location has to offer. It is a short walk or drive from A Wish or Two Ago (French bakery), Foxtail Coffee, Magnolia Wine Bar, Chris Place (farm to table restaurant), unique shops, and Eustis downtown festivals. This home is steps from Lake Gracies walking loop, 5 minutes from Hidden Waters hiking trails, 10 minutes from downtown Mount Dora, 15 20 minutes from many u pick farms, 45 minutes from Walt Disney World, and just over an hour to New Smyrna Beach.
Payment Calculator
- Principal & Interest -
- Property Tax $
- Home Insurance $
- HOA Fees $
- Monthly -
For a Fast & FREE Mortgage Pre-Approval
Apply Now

Features
Similar Properties
Nearby Subdivisions
44 Gables Ph 02a
44 Gables Ph 02b
44 Gables Ph 03
Azalea Park Sub
Brightwater Place Ph 02
Century Oaks Estate 1st Add
Country Club Ridge Sub
Crooked Lake Reserve
Estates At Black Bear Reserve
Eustis
Eustis Badger
Eustis Brac Bluff Pass Ph 02 H
Eustis Century Oak Estates
Eustis Cherrytree On Washingto
Eustis Crippen Crooked View
Eustis Erwins Sub
Eustis Glover Sub
Eustis Goulds Sub
Eustis Grand Island Heights
Eustis Grand Island Heights Su
Eustis Grand Island Shores Add
Eustis Hazzards Homestead
Eustis Heights
Eustis Hermosa Shores
Eustis Hillcrest At Lake Netti
Eustis Hillcrest Sub
Eustis Idlewild Heights
Eustis Knollwood Village
Eustis Lake Eustis Place
Eustis Lake Woodward Oaks
Eustis Lake Yale Landing
Eustis Lakeview Court
Eustis Lakeview Park
Eustis Lynnhurst
Eustis Monte Carlo Sub
Eustis Ocklawaha Sub
Eustis Pinecrest
Eustis Quayle Golf Links
Eustis Ridgeview At Crooked La
Eustis Rosenwald Gardens
Eustis Sentinel Hill
Eustis Springwood Landing Sub
Eustis Townhill
Eustis Tropical Shore
Eustis Villdale Park
Eustis Weavers
Eustis Westgate Sub
Joleen Estates
King Homestead
Mc Cormick Park
Non
None
Not Applicable
Orange Capital Court
Pine Meadows 40s
Pine Meadows Reserve Phase 1a
Pine Ridge
Polak Sub
Quail Hollow
Rainbow Rdg
Rainbow Ridge
Remington Club
Rosenwald Gardens

- Nicole Haltaufderhyde, REALTOR ®
- Tropic Shores Realty
- Mobile: 352.425.0845
- 352.425.0845
- nicoleverna@gmail.com